Surfshark vs. ProtonVPN Comparison Review
Surfshark vs. ProtonVPN, which is the best VPN for you? If you are not sure which VPN provider is worth your time, this is the place to be. We have compared all the essential features, from security and privacy to how they perform in unlocking streaming sites, torrenting, and gaming.
Surfshark and ProtonVPN are among the most popular VPNs on the market. They share quite a lot in common, but ultimately, there are profound differences that should inform your purchase decision.
Surfshark and ProtonVPN have the same encryption and support the same protocols. They also have a no-log policy and are ideal for streaming, torrenting, and gaming. But the difference comes in the number of simultaneous connections allowed, security, jurisdiction, server network, speeds, support, and pricing. Surfshark is a better choice as it allows unlimited connections, works in China, has better speeds, a wider server network of RAM-only servers, and reliable support. Plans are also more affordable. On the other hand, ProtonVPN has a free version, is in a privacy-friendly jurisdiction, has built-in Tor functionality, and is much more expensive..
For more regarding how they compare, read along.
|PCs, Mobile, Routers, TV Sticks, Gaming Consoles
|PCs, Mobile, Routers, Smart TVs, TV Sticks, Gaming Consoles
|256-bit AES encryption
|256-bit AES encryption
|IKEv2/IPsec, OpenVPN, WireGuard
|IKEv2, OpenVPN, WireGuard, and Stealth
|🤷 Logging Policy
|100% No Logging
|No Log (Audited)
|🖥 Server Network
|3,200 servers across 65 countries
|1,900+ servers in 67 countries
|🧪 Leak Tests
|24/7 live chat, FAQ
|🆓 Free Version
|⌛ Free Trial
|30-day money-back guarantee
|30-day money-back guarantee
- All-round protection across PCs, mobile devices, routers, consoles, streaming devices, etc.
- Airtight security courtesy of AES 256-bit encryption
- Excellent value for money as it allows unlimited simultaneous connections
- The server network boasts RAM-only servers for faster speed and enhanced privacy
- It has obfuscated servers that make it a reliable VPN for China, and other countries with strict VPN policies
- It has a robust architecture that offers blazingly fast speeds compared to Proton
- Offers all-round protection for PCs, mobile devices, routers, gaming consoles, TVs, etc
- It has a free version though the servers are in just 3 countries
- Deploys the Diffie-Hellman key exchange for forward secrecy.
- It has built-in Tor functionality for extra security and access to Onion sites safely
- Independently audited no-log policy guarantees 100% privacy and confidentiality
- Located in a 9-Eyes country, so despite having a no-log policy your privacy could be compromised
- It is expensive and allows a maximum of 10 simultaneous connections
- There is no live chat or any other support channel apart from guides
Surfshark vs. ProtonVPN Face-to-Face Comparison Review
Now, onto the day’s main business, how does Surfshark compare to ProtonVPN? To help you make an informed decision, we have compared the two providers based on the critical factors considered when buying a VPN. So, without further ado, let’s get into it.
1. Brand Trust
Today, there are hundreds of VPN brands, some genuine while others are complete trash. That said, you need to first assess the brand’s background and reputation before committing to a subscription. So, which of the two VPNs has the best reputation?
Surfshark is a trusted VPN company founded in 2018, a time when it was available for iOS only, but later on, apps for other platforms were added. The company was formerly owned by Surfshark Ltd. Plans to merge it with Nord Security were initialized in 2021 before the merger was finalized in 2022.
Even though it’s a fairly new brand, it has won the hearts of millions of users. The company was named the best VPN in 2021 by Trusted Review Awards and included in CNET’s Best Overall VPN list in 2022. We did thorough checks on consumer review websites and VPN forums, mainly Reddit, to find out what users and VPN experts are saying.
We are glad it is rated highly. But of course, there are a few dissatisfied users. On Trustpilot, Surfshark has a Trust Score of 4.4/5 after over 21,000 reviews which is pretty impressive.
Like Surfshark, ProtonVPN is a trusted VPN provider that boasts over 70 million users globally. Established in 2017, the brand has risen to be one of the best VPNs on the market.
The employees own the majority of its shares, while the rest are owned by Fondation Genevoise pour l’Innovation Technologique (FONGIT), a not-for-profit organization alongside some of Proton VPN’s users. It has also won awards in several categories. We also did background checks on the brand’s reputation to find out what users are saying, and we are also glad it has good reviews.
However, it’s worth noting that there are some complaints and negative user reviews. On TrustPilot, for example, ProtonVPN has a rating of 2.4/5 after slightly over 400 reviews.
2. Supported Devices
The supported devices is the second aspect to discuss in this Surfshark vs. ProtonVPN comparison review. Here, the aim is to go for a VPN that supports multiple devices so you can get all-round protection across all devices. Besides the supported devices, you should also go for a brand that allows unlimited connections or at least the maximum number of simultaneous connections. So, which brand wins this round?
ProtonVPN also excels in terms of the devices it works with. There are apps for popular PC platforms, talk of Windows, macOS, and Linux. You can also use this VPN to protect Android or iOS mobile devices.
In addition to PC and mobile protection, ProtonVPN works with routers, Smart TVs, Apple TVs, Fire TVs, PlayStation, Xbox, and so on.
ProtonVPN falls short compared to Surfshark because it allows a maximum of 10 simultaneous connections. But this shouldn’t be a big issue as you can connect additional devices via an already connected router.
How user-friendly is the VPN you want to purchase? This should be a huge factor to consider whether you are a techie or a newbie. In this segment, we have compared the usability of Surfshark and ProtonVPN. Check out which one is easy to get started with so you can get online security and protection without hassles.
Surfshark has excellent usability. To get started, click the ‘Get Surfshark’ button, which redirects to the plans page. On the plans page, select a preferred plan and continue to the next step of checking out and creating your account.
Once you have an account, download and install the Surfshark client software on your device. Then launch the app, sign in, select a server, and hit the Connect button.
ProtonVPN is also among the user-friendly VPNs we have tested. The process of getting started is pretty much similar to that of Surfshark.
The first step is clicking the ‘Get ProtonVPN Now’ button, redirecting to the plans page. On the plans page, choose a preferred plan and checkout. You will then need to create an account before downloading the ProtonVPN app, depending on your device.
The last step will be signing in on the app and selecting the desired server before finishing by clicking the Connect button.
4. Security (Encryption)
One of the essential factors to consider when choosing a VPN is encryption technology. Encryption is all about how the VPN encodes and decodes your data. Simply, it’s a way of scrambling your data so other parties can’t understand the information. There are different encryption technologies. So, which ones have the two VPNs in this comparison review deployed?
ProtonVPN also leaves nothing to chance as far as security is concerned. It also deploys the latest military-grade encryption, Advanced Encryption Standard (AES) 256-bit key. With AES 256-bit encryption, it would take millions of years and the fastest computers to perform a successful brute-force attack.
In addition, security is beefed up with HMAC with SHA384 for authentication and 4096-bit RSA as the key exchange. Also worth mentioning is the Diffie-Hellman key exchange for forward secrecy.
5. Security (Protocols)
Besides encryption, it is also vital to consider the protocols supported by the VPN you are about to purchase. Also known as tunneling methods, a VPN protocol is a set of rules that dictate how your data will be routed from the device you are using to the different servers. Today, there are different protocols, each with its capabilities, advantages, and disadvantages. The rule of thumb when selecting a VPN is to go for one that has multiple protocols.
ProtonVPN is not different from Surfshark as it also features just three tunneling methods.
First is IKEv2, which is fast and takes security to the next level courtesy of Diffie-Hellman, implementing forward secrecy.
The other protocol is OpenVPN, the industry standard protocol known for security. Last is WireGuard, which is ultrafast and deploys ChaCha20 encryption for maximum security.
6. Security Extras
While a VPN’s encryption technology and protocols matter, there are plenty of other security features to look for. There are essential security extras and advanced security features that take security and the VPN experience a notch higher. In this segment, check out which security extras the two VPNs tag along with and their function.
Surfshark is well endowed when it comes to security extras. One of the basic features it boasts is DNS and IP Leak Protection, which ensures your DNS requests and IP address don’t leak inadvertently. Another extra is a kill switch which disconnects your device from the internet immediately after the VPN connection drops so your traffic won’t be exposed.
Another security extra worth mentioning is CleanWeb which includes features such as ads trackers for an ad-free internet experience and malware and phishing blockers. Surfshark also has a split tunneling feature dubbed Bypasser, which allows you to decide what traffic to route via the VPN and what traffic should connect to the internet resource directly.
Last is Camouflage Mode, which adds a layer of security such that even your ISP won’t be aware of your activity. You can also opt for Surfshark One, a new bundle that includes the Surfshark VPN and Surfshark Antivirus.
There’s also Surfshark Search which prevents tracking so you can get real organic results, Surfshark Alert which detects breaches, and Incogni, which keeps data brokers at bay.
ProtonVPN is also a robust VPN with plenty of security extras. First is DNS Leak Prevention which protects all your DNS queries. There’s also a Kill Switch and Always-on VPN that prevent your traffic from leaking when the VPN connection drops, so at no time will your data be compromised.
Another excellent security feature is Secure Core architecture which gives ProtonVPN the unique ability to defend against network-based traffic. ProtonVPN can also protect you from malware and block ads courtesy of NetShield, a DNS filtering feature.
Another top feature is Forward Secrecy which ensures that your encrypted traffic can’t be deciphered even if the encryption key from previous sessions falls into the wrong hands. ProtonVPN is also among the few VPNs that support port forwarding, which speeds up the overall performance of the VPN.
Last is Tor over VPN, which enables you to route all your traffic via the Tor Anonymity Network, guaranteeing security and facilitating access to Onion sites.
7. Privacy & Confidentiality (Jurisdiction)
VPNs are not just for security; they also offer privacy and confidentiality. One of the critical aspects to consider under privacy is the jurisdiction where the VPN is based. There are countries where the authorities compromise privacy and confidentiality. You can not be sure of your privacy and confidentiality in such countries. That said, you need to go for a VPN in a privacy-friendly jurisdiction So, how do the two VPNs in this review square out?
ProtonVPN is the best choice in this segment as it is based in Switzerland, a country that is not part of any surveillance organization, be it 5-Eyes, 9-Eyes, or 14-Eyes.
That means the country is not obligated to cooperate with members of these surveillance organizations, so your privacy and confidentiality are not under compromise. Switzerland has long been known to be a country that respects the online privacy of its citizens.
However, as a word of caution, the Swiss authorities cooperate with international security agencies such as Europol, so you must play safe.
8. Privacy & Confidentiality (Log Policy)
Concerning privacy and confidentiality, it’s not just about the VPNs jurisdiction; the logging policy also matters. Of course, the best VPN should have a strict no-log policy. None of your personally identifiable information should be logged. But while most VPNs claim to have a strict no-log policy, some have been caught pants down logging crucial user data. So, what’s the logging policy of Surfshark and ProtonVPN? Can they be trusted?
ProtonVPN also has a strict no-log policy. The company doesn’t keep any personally identifiable information that can jeopardize your online privacy and confidentiality. The VPN does not log the websites you visit, your traffic, IP address, session length, location, or any other information that can be traced back to you.
Unlike many VPN providers whose no-log policy is questionable, ProtonVPN’s no-log policy is credible. As a matter of fact, it has been independently verified, so you can be sure that none of your information is stored.
9. Server Network and Distribution
The server network of a VPN can also be the deal maker or breaker, so check what kind of servers the VPN provider has. Always go for a VPN with the highest number of servers distributed across the globe for reliability. And it’s not just about the server network. Specialized servers will also do you good. There are ultrafast servers designed to offer fast speeds, P2P-friendly servers for P2P sharing, streaming servers, and so on. Now, how does the server network of Surfshark compare to that of ProtonVPN?
At the core of Surfshark’s architecture is a robust server network of over 3200 highly specialized servers. The servers are located in 65 countries in Europe, the Americas, Asia Pacific, the Middle East, and Africa.
One salient feature of these servers is speed. Each server has at least a single 1Gbps port, while 10Gbps ports are onboarded daily. For the record, Surfshark shifted to RAM-only servers that wipe all data with every reboot, so you can be sure that no data is stored.
There are also specialized servers, for example, obfuscated servers that offer an extra layer of privacy, virtual servers that offer faster speeds and cover more locations, and private DNS servers that bypass your local DNS and prevent blocks.
ProtonVPN also has a decent server network comprising over 1750 servers spread in 64 countries across the globe. Even though they are not RAM-only servers, they have full disk encryption for enhanced security. Most of these servers are ultrafast with 2Gbps ports, but there are also select servers with 10Gbps capabilities.
One unique feature worth mentioning is Secure Cores servers that route your traffic via servers in privacy-friendly countries for enhanced privacy. The 97 Secure Core servers are owned and operated by ProtonVPN. Secure Core servers are exclusively for Plus plan subscribers. Also worth mentioning is Plus servers which are also available for Plus plan subscribers only.
They work with NetShield, and support streaming and P2P sharing. Proton also has free VPN servers, but only in three countries, the United States, the Netherlands, and Japan. One cool feature is Quick Country Selector, which connects you to the best servers with no congestion.
10. Speeds and Performance
The speeds and performance of VPNs is another crucial factor to consider, especially if you are into torrenting, P2P sharing, and gaming. You need to understand that even the best VPNs around incur speed losses. The speed loss arises from the transfer of data via multiple servers. Now, VPNs have different speed losses depending on the infrastructure so when looking for the best VPN for you, check the speeds. The best VPNs have a speed loss averaging 20-30%, but others incur higher speed losses of up to 70%.
As usual, we test the speeds of all the VPNs we review. Surfshark and ProtonVPN were no exceptions. We tested them on a 100Mbps connection to see how fast they would download a 1Gb file and the different speed losses on servers in several countries. Below are the results.
|🇬🇧 United Kingdom
|🇬🇧 United Kingdom
11. Streaming, Torrenting, and Gaming
Today, the applications of VPNs go beyond online security and privacy. They can also open up a whole new world of opportunities. One of the common applications of these tools is streaming. They have the capability of unblocking geo-restricted content. They can also facilitate safe torrenting and P2P sharing, which many ISPs loathe. Lastly, VPNs come in handy for gamers. But not all of the VPNs out there are up to these tasks. So, let’s find out what Surfshark and ProtonVPN can do and what they can’t.
Surfshark is a reliable VPN for streaming. It can unblock several libraries with geo-locked content, for example, Netflix, Hulu, BBC iPlayer, Popcorn Time Paramount+, and Kodi. You are good to go as long as you connect to streaming-friendly servers.
Besides unblocking streaming sites, Surfshark is ideal for safe and secure torrenting. We launched several torrenting sessions, and Surfshark performed exceptionally. We downloaded several huge files and at no time did we experience bandwidth throttling as the VPN’s robust architecture hid our torrenting activity. For the record, Surfshark doesn’t explicitly prohibit torrenting as long as torrenting is not banned in your country.
Lastly, Surfshark can help gamers protect themselves from DDoS attacks, which are common nowadays. It can also enable them to access geo-locked gaming content such as maps as well as discounts. Surfshark can also help gamers improve performance and lower pings.
ProtonVPN is also a trusted VPN for streaming. It can unblock a wide range of streaming sites with a high success rate, just like Surfshark. In our tests, we managed to unblock Netflix US, Netflix Japan, and Netflix Canada alongside other streaming sites, including Hulu, BBC iPlayer, Kodi, Crunchyroll, and Paramount+, among others.
But make sure to connect to streaming-optimized servers. Just to mention, the free servers are not streaming-friendly, so you need a paid plan to access streaming servers.
Regarding torrenting, it is also ideal. Here again, we launched several torrenting sessions, and at no time did the speeds drop due to bandwidth throttling.
On gaming, it is also a decent VPN that can protect gamers from DDoS attacks and other threats that linger in the gaming scene. Proton is also suitable for accessing geo-locked content and gaming discounts and will also enhance performance and lower pings for lag free gameplay.
12. Customer Support
When selecting a VPN to buy, it’s also a worthy undertaking to assess the provider’s customer support. This is regardless of whether you are a noob or a techie who knows the ins and outs of VPNs. Some newbies will definitely need help when getting started or configuring the VPN. Similarly, expert-level users might face some glitches they can’t sort out, including billing issues. All said and done, customer support is paramount. So, how do the two compare in this round?
Unfortunately, ProtonVPN doesn’t have a robust customer support infrastructure like Surfshark. Despite being a top brand, there is no live chat option. This is one of the reasons the brand has very low ratings on TrustPilot.
Instead, Proton has a support center where many user issues have been addressed. Well, this is an excellent addition, but at the end of the day, not all issues have been covered.
But we like the fact that the company has plenty of guides and tutorials that users can leverage to get out of the muck.
13. Plans, Pricing & Payment Methods
The last aspect to compare is the pricing. You definitely want a VPN with a good mix of features, but pricing matters now that you don’t want to break the bank.
|Starter $1.99 / mo
One $2.69 / mo
One+ $3.99 / mo
|4.99 € / mo
|Starter $3.49 / mo
One $4.09 / mo
One+ $6.49 / mo
|5.99 € / mo
|Starter $10.99 / mo
One $14.99 / mo
One+ $21.99 / mo
|9.99 € / mo
Frequently Asked Questions
1. How long can you use Proton VPN for free?
2. Does Proton VPN sell your data?
3. Are Surfshark and NordVPN the same company?
4. Why is Proton VPN so slow?
5. Can Surfshark VPN be hacked?
There you have it, folks, a Surfshark vs. ProtonVPN comparison review. As you have seen, both providers offer excellent security and privacy with a good mix of security extras. They are also ideal for streaming, torrenting and gaming. So, what’s the best choice? ProtonVPN is a robust free VPN, so if you don’t want to pay a dime, you can take advantage of the ProtonVPN free version. But note there are several limitations with the free version. However, if you want the best value for money, go with Surfshark. It is cheaper, allows unlimited connections, and offers faster speeds.